Because Christianity is bigger than Biblical manhood or Biblical womanhood (Blog of Retha Faurie)

sullivan_man_upI have heard variations of this question more than once, usually from guys who have very misogynous views. But this is IMO a worthy question: Why should men “man up” and women should not “woman up?” To quote one of the askers in his own words:

Men have tons of programs in the church to “Man up!” Either they are stupid or women are more moral, which one is it?

I answered him this way:

Your “man up” question is actually a good one. There are men’s programs in the church, and even more women’s programs1.

But men are asked to step up, and women asked to not usurp, to step down, to encourage men to lead. No, men are not stupider, nor are women more moral. The point is that people with a men-should-lead view see, when men and women are equally wise and equally involved in decision making, men who should step up and women who should step down.

They teach men they are falling short, because they expect men to have more leadership positions, more leadership qualities and more leadership responsibility. They also teach women they are falling short, but in other ways: Women are allegedly not good enough followers, not “affirming the leadership of men” well enough, not having the gifts to speak and lead in church. Being asked to “step up”, when you don’t have the gifts for the expected task, is another side of the coin of women asked to “step down” when they do have the gifts.

Feminists are not asking that much of men. Christian feminists ask men and women to work for God by their gifts, not their gender, to lead only where God calls them to.

We don’t ask men to man up. “Up” implies higher, and “man up” means that going higher is suitable for men, not women. Feminists don’t see a hierarchy whereby one gender should be higher.

 —————————

1 Perhaps churches have more women’s ministries than men’s ministries because men with a teaching or leading gift can use it in many places and thus have many choices of what to do besides men’s ministry, while women with a leading or teaching gift can often hardly use it outside women’s ministry.

Advertisements

Comments on: "Why are men asked to “man up”? A good question from a hostile source" (2)

  1. According to Joe Ehrmann, former coach and NFL player, the three most destructive words a boy can hear as he is growing up is, “Be a man.” We lay the foundation for male violence when we tell boys that to be a man is to decry “feminine” characteristics, and to gain respect through male aggression. It sends them the message that they are to be tough and violent. So, no, we should not be encouraging men to “man up”.

    It doesn’t mean women are more moral either. Where did that come from anyway??

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Gifts??? Women are not allowed to have gifts.
    In most Southern Baptist churches, only men are allowed to have the gifts mentioned by the Apostle Paul.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: