Because Christianity is bigger than Biblical manhood or Biblical womanhood (Blog of Retha Faurie)

It is the feminization of the church“, some experts claim. “The churches are run in a way that soothes female ears more than male ears, that caters more to women’s needs than men’s.”

That is a perfectly reasonable answer, but is it the whole truth? And it matters. God’s heart is for both males and females to love Him and live for Him.

According to this “feminization” theory, men don’t like singing love songs to God, flower arrangements in the church, emotional preaching, etc. And little more than the feminized men stay in churches, as those are the only ones not too upset with things like this.

Can this be the whole truth? King Solomon, for example, wrote and sung love songs, some of which are collected in the Bible as “Song of Songs”. His father, David, sang of God’s love and wrote Psalms. Neither of the two strikes me as effeminate. And today’s male, love-song-singing stars? Well, by what the tabloids write about some of them, it wouldn’t seem pansies are the only men who sing love songs.

It also seems that the more emotional churches tend to have more people- both male and female – than the less emotional ones. I may not be crazy about emotionalism, but emotional congregations grow in membership.

And does anyone seriously believe that flower arrangements in church keep men away?

Perhaps something else, way more foundational to the male mindset, is a big part of the reason. I suggest this because if the real cause of the illness is not diagnosed, there is little chance of curing the patient. (Our patient is the church; the symptom is a shortage of men.)

Sex may be the answer.

1. Men are very interested in sex.

2. The church says the sexual act belongs inside of marriage.

3: Current laws in many countries (divorce laws, custody laws, domestic violence laws) make it riskier than before for men to get married.

4. Today’s society frowns less on women who are willing to sleep around without marriage. Consequently, more women willingly sleep around.

When the church asks men to get married, they are asking them to do something risky, with many potential drawbacks. And the primary short-term benefit that men previously had by marrying, could be obtained easily without a wedding ring.

I humbly suggest the Christian view on sexual morality may be a bigger stumbling block for men than ever before, something they prefer not to heed. And this makes them believe that God’s laws are not relevant to the real world.

Is this the church’s fault? Probably not. The man’s fault? Largely.  Society’s fault? Partly. Now, if this is true, what should the church do to get more men? Change men’s thinking? Change society? How?


PS Update: This link gives a more balanced view of church feminization than most proponents do.

Comments on: "Why are there more women than men in church? One possible answer." (3)

  1. Michael Adams said:

    One clue that you may be right is that the drop in men’s attendance began not so long after the changes in marriage and family laws, which have increased the risks of marriage for men.

    There’s another, though, which is not related. More educated men used to be the ones who’d fill the pews. They were more accustomed to thinking in abstractions, which include theology, sin, morality, an afterlife. Now, education is largely conducted by antireligious people, so a goodly number of men just assume that it’s all nonsense. Women will sometimes put their intellects in neutral on Sunday morning, for the emotional fulfillment that they receive in church, so there are more of them there, than men.

    I’d also say that, in many churches, the clergy can often be mistaken for eunuchs, and this is off-putting for men. Note that in what you have described as the more emotional churches, the minister may be quite virile in affect, which draws women, but does not put men off.

    We need seminaries with football teams.


  2. Roxeanne de Luca said:

    ROFL to “seminaries with football teams”. Probably true.

    The idea that flowers in churches turn “men” off is laughable. Real men don’t care (and actually spend so much of their lives kicking butt and taking names that they are happy to take a break from that for an hour every week), just like they don’t get hung up on “Wives, submit to your husbands”, because they know that both women and men submit to real authority and don’t submit to imposters.

    Moving right along, you are dead-on correct with the Church and sexuality. In the long run, men benefit from the Church’s teachings (and form marrying a woman who is in the marriage to build a family, not to get a meal ticket), but by the time they’ve figured that out, they are older and have gotten far out of the habit of attending church.

    I think that the best way to get more men into church is to recruit women to do it. Aside from the fact that they can drag their husbands and sons in, women who live chastely can change the culture. In our rush to be non-judgmental, we’ve allowed slutty women to run amok, ruin men, and then claim that we are the ones with hang-ups. Let’s try getting back to the idea that women who are marriage material simply do not behave that way, and if you want to get married, never have sex after you are married, and then get divorced and taken to the cleaners, marry a woman who doesn’t follow the Christian (or Jewish, or Muslim, or Hindu, or whatever) guidelines.


  3. Thank you for the comments. Perhaps the feminization of the church is a result, not a cause, of men staying away? The church is probably catering to the members they have – which are disproportionally female.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: